Jersey Mike’s Subs

Reviews

• Suzie N.

  star star star star star 1 June 2026

  Needed three boxes of sandwiches for a church event on a Sunnday, Jersey Mike's did a great job. All three boxes were ready as we ordered them. Price was better than another place and tasted better. Good packaging easy to carry; at the store the boxes were carried out to my car. Place is clean doesn't smell like a subway sandwich place.  Had to go into the store to order the catering on line wasn't helpful.

• James M.

  star star star star star 25 May 2026

  Met my brother for an early lunch, just before 11:00, trying to beat the lunch rush. While we managed to beat the rush, my buffalo chicken wrap took entirely too long to prepare. The staff, particularly the grill guy, seemed a little disorganized. The good news is the staff was friendly and the wrap was decent, although it could have used a more robust, hotter buffalo sauce. Since it only recently opened, I'll chalk up the slow service to inexperience and I imagine it will get better so I plan to visit again ... and try a different wrap or sandwich.
  
  After the General Manager, Lawrence, reached out after my original review, I made a second trip with a coworker. She had the #11, which used to be the Stickball Special and I had the #13, The Original Italian. We both enjoyed our respective subs which provided healthy portions of meats, tasty vinegar and oil, and fresh bread. As on the the first visit, the staff was very friendly. I would place Jersey Mike's at the top of my list of sub/sandwich shops here in Sierra Vista. I will definitely be visiting again.

• Jim C.

  star star star star star_border 23 May 2026

  I give this place a generous four stars.  Honestly, considering that we are in SV, it should be five, because everywhere else sucks.  I would have gone three stars but the staff was efficient and friendly, so kudos to them.
  
  That said, as a Philly native, I am well versed in what a good hoagie should have, number one being the bread...if your bread sucks, the rest of it will.  The bread here isn't bad at all.  Sure it isn't an Amoroso roll, but it still has a nice chew to it.  The meats and cheeses are not bad and of course they have the requisite toppings (lettuce, onion, tomato, oil, vinegar, italian spices, etc).  
  
  I got the classic Italian, which is my litmus test for hoagies.  If a sandwich shop can't make one wrll, everything else is bound to stink.  It was pretty good though, I will be back for sure.
  
  Bottom line, they are the closest thing you can get in SV to a true east coast hoagie, though the prices are a bit high.

• Meilinda H.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  The only reason for 4 out of 5 stars is because of it being a new store and working out all the kinks.
  The food is really good, cheese steak being my favorite so far.
  The manager is awesome, if there are any issues I suggest you let him know, he will do his best to take care of it right away.
  Very busy but not a huge  time between ordering and receiving food, could be faster but again it's a new store. They will get better.

• Jack G.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 18 May 2026

  What a difference 3 days make!  Same great food but the order wasn't ready on time as promised.  Customers were waiting longer than I.  Rumor was the Trainers fro
  PS:  Don't get a tuna sub as a wrap; Ultra messy.
  Just constructive criticism.